Utah Unit Fillmore, Oak Creek Bighorn Sheep Hunting Guide
Utah Unit Fillmore, Oak Creek offers one of the most sought-after bighorn sheep hunts in the state, and it belongs squarely in the conversation for hunters serious about pursuing this species in Utah. Bighorn sheep tags are among the hardest permits to draw anywhere in the West, and Fillmore, Oak Creek is no exception — a unit where tags are issued in single digits or low double digits each year and demand from residents and nonresidents alike remains extremely high.
This article breaks down what the available harvest history, application structure, and terrain themes tell hunters who are considering putting in for this unit, along with realistic expectations for anyone lucky enough to draw a tag.
HuntPilot Analysis: Is Fillmore, Oak Creek Worth Applying For?
For bighorn sheep hunters, the honest answer is yes — with the caveat that this is a long-term investment for most applicants, not a unit anyone should expect to draw quickly. Utah's bighorn sheep tags are managed as extremely limited, high-demand permits statewide, and Fillmore, Oak Creek fits that mold. Both resident and nonresident applicants should expect this to be a multi-year, points-driven pursuit, and hunters should check HuntPilot's Utah unit page for current draw statistics before deciding how to allocate their points.
What makes Fillmore, Oak Creek stand out is what happens once a hunter actually draws. The harvest data available for this unit shows a 100% success rate across every recent season on record: 12 hunters harvested 12 rams in 2025, 11 of 11 in 2024, 11 of 11 in 2023, and 17 of 17 in 2022. That is a perfect four-year run with zero unsuccessful hunters. For a species where success is never guaranteed and terrain, weather, and ram movement can all conspire against a hunter in a short season, a sustained 100% success rate is a strong signal that this unit's sheep are both huntable and that tag holders are putting in the scouting time and effort required to close the deal.
This kind of success rate typically reflects a combination of a healthy, visible sheep population and hunters who treat a bighorn tag as the once-in-a-lifetime opportunity it is — investing heavily in scouting, guides, and time afield rather than treating it casually. Given the tag fees involved, that intensity of effort is expected, but it's still worth noting that the data backs up the reputation: hunters who draw this tag have historically gone home with a ram.
Harvest Success Rates
The four most recent seasons of harvest data for Fillmore, Oak Creek show a remarkably consistent pattern:
- 2025: 12 hunters, 12 harvested — 100% success
- 2024: 11 hunters, 11 harvested — 100% success
- 2023: 11 hunters, 11 harvested — 100% success
- 2022: 17 hunters, 17 harvested — 100% success
Across these four years, every single hunter who drew a tag in this unit filled it. That's 51 hunters and 51 rams over four seasons with no misses recorded in the data. For context, most big game hunts — even well-managed ones — see some percentage of hunters go home empty-handed due to weather, access issues, or simply not connecting with a legal animal in the time allotted. A unit that posts 100% success rates year after year suggests both a stable, accessible sheep population and a hunter base that is well-prepared and well-supported once they draw.
It's worth noting that tag numbers here are small — ranging from 11 to 17 hunters per year in the recorded data — which is typical for bighorn sheep management. These are not high-volume hunts; they are precision opportunities extended to a handful of hunters annually, and the state manages the population accordingly.
Trophy Quality
Trophy record data was not available for this unit in the structured data provided. Hunters interested in the trophy potential of rams taken from Fillmore, Oak Creek should consult HuntPilot's unit page and Utah's published harvest reports, which may include ram measurements and age data from recent seasons. Without verified record-book entries or scoring data specific to this unit, any claim about trophy quality here would be speculation, and that's not a risk worth taking when hunters are making decisions involving tag fees in the thousands of dollars.
Access & Terrain
Specific elevation, acreage, and public land percentage figures were not available in the structured data for this unit. What can be said, drawing on general terrain themes associated with Utah bighorn sheep country, is that these hunts typically take hunters into steep, rugged terrain with rock outcroppings, canyon systems, and open slopes where sheep can be spotted and stalked from a distance. Hunters preparing for this unit should plan on serious physical conditioning and extended glassing sessions, as is standard for bighorn sheep hunting throughout the West.
Because exact public land percentage, elevation range, and total acreage were not provided in the data available for this article, hunters should use HuntPilot's mapping tools — including public land overlays — to identify accessible terrain within the unit boundaries before the season. Scouting trips ahead of a hunt are strongly recommended given the difficulty and cost associated with a bighorn sheep tag; hunters generally cannot afford to waste time in the field once the season opens.
How to Apply
Utah's bighorn sheep draw for Fillmore, Oak Creek follows the state's standard application calendar, and the requirements differ meaningfully between residents and nonresidents.
Given how limited bighorn sheep tags are statewide, and specifically in a unit like Fillmore, Oak Creek where only a small handful of tags are issued annually, hunters should treat this as a long-term point-building strategy rather than a one-time application. Check HuntPilot's Utah unit page for current draw odds and point requirements before applying, as these figures shift from year to year.
Application dates and fees change every draw cycle. For the current deadlines, fees, and draw odds, see HuntPilot's Utah page at /states/ut.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Fillmore, Oak Creek worth applying for as a bighorn sheep unit?
Based on the available harvest data, yes. The unit has posted a 100% success rate across the last four recorded seasons (2022–2025), meaning every hunter who drew a tag and hunted this unit harvested a ram. That level of consistency is a strong indicator that the unit supports a huntable, visible sheep population and that drawn hunters are well-prepared. The main hurdle is drawing the tag itself, which requires significant point investment for both residents and nonresidents given how limited bighorn sheep tags are in Utah generally.
What is harvest success like in Fillmore, Oak Creek?
Harvest success has been perfect in every year of available data. In 2025, 12 of 12 hunters harvested a ram. In 2024 and 2023, 11 of 11 hunters were successful each year. In 2022, all 17 hunters who drew tags harvested rams. This 100% success rate across four consecutive seasons is exceptional even by bighorn sheep standards, where success is typically high but not universal.
How big are the bighorn sheep in Fillmore, Oak Creek?
Trophy scoring data for this specific unit was not available in the structured data used for this article. Hunters wanting detailed ram size and age-class information should check HuntPilot's unit page and Utah's published harvest summary reports, which often include measurements from recently harvested rams.
What is the terrain like in Fillmore, Oak Creek?
Specific elevation range, total acreage, and public land percentage were not available in the data reviewed for this unit. Bighorn sheep terrain across Utah generally involves steep, rocky slopes, canyon rims, and open vantage points suited to long-range glassing, and hunters should expect a physically demanding hunt. Hunters should use HuntPilot's mapping tools to study public land boundaries and terrain features within the unit ahead of a scouting trip or hunt.
How much does a bighorn sheep tag cost in Fillmore, Oak Creek?
Fees and deadlines change every draw cycle, so the current figures live on HuntPilot's Utah page at /states/ut rather than here.